The Clarion Call of Truth: Melissa Harris Perry on the Welfare Debate

As anyone who speaks to me knows, I am an avid fan of the awesome Melissa Harris Perry. I’ve been insufferably proud ever since she got her own show on MSNBC this year. Why? Because she is an anomaly. What do you think of when you think of Black women on TV? Don’t answer that. The sad fact is that there are not a lot of intelligent, female commentators on TV, certainly not of African American descent. If I had children, MHP would be required watching.

Race aside, she puts the A in awesome. Her accolades are many. Check out her website. There is also a great piece on the show here.

There are things about a person that can’t be told by a string of accomplishments, or the letters after their name. When you listen to Melissa speak she invariably comes across as an intelligent, compassionate, respectful and fair minded person committed to social justice. There is a authenticity that shines through whenever she speaks which underscores that in spite of life’s good fortune, she never forgets where she came from and her commitment to truth is unwavering. That is something to be honored in a world where people frequently gloss over the truth for personal gain. To boot, I learn something on her show every single week. I would LOVE to be a student in any class she taught.

She did something absolutely stellar on her TV show on September 1st. She spoke truth with a passionate, ferocity that pushed every other consideration out of your head. Hearing her, you could not doubt that she was espousing a deeply held belief based on personal experience. Every person of conscience I know, who bemoans the state of the impoverished in America today, APPLAUDED her unvarnished, guttural response to the continual round of lies being pushed by the GOP about what it means to be poor and who is “worthy” of help in our society. The racial undertones which infect the welfare debate are undeniable and we turn a blind eye to them to our peril. Monica Mehta was completely out of her league, not to mention being rather moronic and close minded throughout the entire show. Personally, I yelled at the TV several times cause Monica was working my last nerve with her one sided/minded rhetoric. Just goes to show, a good education is no substitute for experience…or heart.

Also? When truth speaks, people sit up and LISTEN.

Here is the moment that got everyone talking, on Twitter, on Huff Post, in the LA Times, ad infinitum:

“What is riskier than living poor in America? Seriously, what in the world is riskier than being a poor person in America? I live in a neighborhood where people are shot on my street corner. I live in a neighborhood where people have to figure out how to get their kid into school because maybe it’ll be a good school and maybe it won’t. I am sick of the idea that being wealthy is risky. No! There is a huge safety net that whenever you fail will catch you and catch you and catch you. Being poor is what is risky. We have to create a safety net for poor people. And when we won’t, because they happen to look different from us, it is the pervasive ugliness! We cannot do that!” Melissa Harris Perry Show, MSNBC

You can watch the whole segment which is definitely watchworthy 😉

This might be the moment to weigh in on the Welfare debate but I will abstain as my already overtaxed brain is not up to the task and I need to catch up on last weekend’s MHP episodes….

6 thoughts on “The Clarion Call of Truth: Melissa Harris Perry on the Welfare Debate”

  1. A passionate woman who speaks her mind and is fearless–what’s not to love? My question is when are we going to get this kind of woman in the Oval office? I am so ready for a woman president! Seriously! Methinks it’s time we send the right “man” to do the job! ha! I definitely have to catch one of Melissa’s shows, lady!

  2. Hi, I saw your blog via Somer Empresses’. Great post and I’m glad Harris-Perry called her out for putting words in her mouth – that seems to be the tactic du jour. I love her program and although she’s very good at being balanced, I actually wish she added more commentary because she’s so intelligent. In all honesty I got fed up with MSNBC in general because of their silence on climate change and their ads for big oil. But I still watch Perry’s show because she’s that good.

    I couldn’t believe the GOP were bragging with that theme of “We Built It”. Really? What did they build? From what I understand nearly all of them were born into wealthy families. How is that considered succeeding from the ground up?

    1. Hi Amelie,

      Thanks for stopping by. Tactic du jour! I love that 🙂 and sadly it’s all too true. The constant bickering makes me crazy but that seems to be the lot of the human race. It seems that we’ve set our standards to high since politics is taking bickering, partisan and otherwise, to an art form.

      I confess that I am a MSNBC junkie. I love Melissa, Rachel, Martin, Ed and sometimes Chris Hayes. Nonetheless, like you. I am stymied and disgusted at the oil aids. What are they thinking? Your point about climate change is a good one and with Chris’ latest commercial, I’m hoping they begin to cover it in more depth as well.



  3. I absolutely love Melissa Harris Perry. She’s smart, spot on, and beautiful, too. I love Saturday mornings watching her talk about women and their reproductive rights and what the Repubs are trying to do. She had on this other woman, her name was Monica like mine, but I can’t recall her last name. Anyway, she was clearly a Repub and I couldn’t believe the things she was saying, but Melissa handled it beautifully. I’m so proud of MSNBC for bringing her on!

Leave a Reply to Coco Rivers Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s